SecBot SecBot
SECBOTREPLAY Home › Report › SBUX

SBUX · The Fifth Circuit vacated and remanded an NLRB decision that had found…

STARBUCKS CORP · COURT-RULING filed May 13, 2026 at 20:00 ET

At the news

BULLISHIMPACT 5/10

COURT-RULING filed May 13, 2026 at 20:00 ET

The Fifth Circuit vacated and remanded an NLRB decision that had found Starbucks unlawfully terminated a union organizer at a Latham, NY store. The court held the NLRB failed to adequately consider contradictory evidence regarding the employee's extreme profanity and other infractions. The ruling is a procedural win for Starbucks, the case returns to the Board for reconsideration, but the court's strong criticism of the Board's reasoning increases the likelihood Starbucks ultimately prevails on the termination issue. The second finding (unlawful impression of surveillance at a Stuyvesant store) was not challenged on appeal and remains intact.

  • Fifth Circuit GRANTED Starbucks' petition for review, VACATED the NLRB's decision, and REMANDED for further proceedings consistent with the opinion.
  • The court found the NLRB failed to adequately consider evidence that the terminated employee used extreme sexist profanity toward a coworker and supervisor, had prior profanity-related discipline, failed closing tasks while on final warning, and opened official NLRB mail.
  • The ruling only concerns the Latham store termination; the Stuyvesant store 'unlawful impression of surveillance' finding was not appealed and remains in effect.
  • Judge Oldham concurred but would have ruled for Starbucks outright without remand, calling the Board's decision 'not the stuff of reasonable, fairminded adjudication.'

Replay the market's reaction

Step through every 5 minutes around the news, then see how it compares with similar events.

Subscribe for Full Access