COURT-RULING filed Sep 9, 2026 at 20:00 ET
Three procedural court rulings in the Northern District of California on September 10, 2026, all favorable to Meta. In the consolidated copyright discovery dispute (Cognella, et al. v. Meta), Magistrate Judge Hixson denied plaintiffs' motions to compel OpenAI and Anthropic for market substitution, licensing, and torrenting evidence, finding the discovery requests irrelevant, overly broad, and disproportionate. In a separate order, Judge Hixson addressed a routine discovery deadline extension request. In De Los Santos v. Meta, a new personal injury case was referred for determination of whether it is related to the multi-district litigation (MDL) on social media adolescent addiction. These rulings are procedural wins for Meta, limiting discovery burdens in the copyright cases and routing a new case into the existing MDL framework, but none represent a final judgment on the merits or a material change in financial exposure for a $1.6T company. The rulings are neutral with low impact, as they are interlocutory and involve no damages or injunctions.