At the news
? NEUTRALIMPACT 2/10 COURT-RULING filed Feb 16, 2026 at 19:00 ET
Two California Lemon Law cases brought by individual plaintiffs against General Motors LLC were remanded back to state court by separate federal district judges in the C.D. Cal. The court in *Gaytan* granted remand because GM failed to prove the amount in controversy exceeded $75,000 for diversity jurisdiction, excluding speculative civil penalties. The court in *Portillo* granted remand because GM's removal was untimely, it waited 32 days after plaintiff disclosed the vehicle purchase price, which made removability 'unequivocally clear and certain' under Ninth Circuit precedent. Both rulings are procedural losses for GM with zero monetary award, no injunction, and no precedential impact beyond these two individual warranty disputes.
- Gaytan v. GM: complaint alleged transmission defects in a 2021 Chevy Silverado 1500; court excluded speculative civil penalties from amount-in-controversy, finding GM failed to meet its burden for diversity jurisdiction; remanded to LA Superior Court.
- Portillo v. GM: complaint alleged defects in a 2020 Cadillac XT6; GM removed 32 days after plaintiff disclosed the $50,304.96 purchase price, triggering the second 30-day removal clock under §1446(b); court found removal untimely and remanded.
- Neither ruling awarded damages or attorney's fees to the plaintiffs; both courts denied fee requests.
- Both rulings are procedural remands on procedural grounds, no merits ruling on GM's vehicle quality or potential liability.
Before · The news · First close · A day later · A week later
Replay the market's reaction
Step through every 5 minutes around the news, then see how it compares with similar events.
Subscribe for Full Access