At the news
? BEARISHIMPACT 5/10 COURT-RULING filed Aug 9, 2026 at 20:00 ET
The Federal Circuit vacated the PTAB's IPR decision invalidating Dental Monitoring's patent claims, ruling that the Board applied the wrong legal standard for determining whether a prior art reference (Carrier) qualifies for an earlier effective filing date. The court held that Carrier must satisfy the written description requirement of § 112(a) to be prior art, not merely 'ministerial' requirements. The case is remanded for the Board to reassess Carrier's prior art status under the correct standard. This is a procedural loss for Align, the patent claims are not reinstated, but the invalidity finding is undone pending remand, reopening uncertainty around the '409 patent.
- Federal Circuit vacated PTAB's final written decision that had found claims 1-15 of Dental Monitoring's '409 patent unpatentable as obvious.
- Court held that to qualify as prior art under AIA § 102(d)(2), a reference patent must satisfy the written description requirement of § 112(a) for at least one of its claims, not merely 'ministerial' requirements.
- Case remanded to PTAB to determine whether Carrier's provisional application provides written description support for Carrier's claims.
- In a related decision, claims 1, 7, and 12 of the '409 patent were already found directed to ineligible subject matter, limiting the scope of remand.
Before · The news · First close · A day later · A week later
Replay the market's reaction
Step through every 5 minutes around the news, then see how it compares with similar events.
Subscribe for Full Access